Vladimir_Nesov comments on indexical uncertainty and the Axiom of Independence - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (70)
(Just to be sure, I expect this is exactly the point you've changed your mind about, so there is no need for me to argue.)
Does not compute. Utility can't be "in given world" or "useful" or "useful from a given world". Utility is a measure of stuff, not stuff itself. Measure has no location.
Not if we interpret "utility" as meaning "valuable stuff". It's not generally correct that the same stuff is equally valuable in all possible worlds. If in worlds of both agents A and B we can produce stuff X and Y, it might well be that producing X is world A has more B-utility than producing Y in world A, but producing X in world B has less B-utility than producing Y in world B. At the same time, given amount of B-utility is equally valuable, no matter where the stuff measured so got produced.
Yes. I agree fully with the above post.
But can certainly be location dependent. Measure doesn't have to be translation invariant. Hyperbolic discounting, for instance.