Comment author:Alicorn
02 August 2009 07:42:21PM
4 points
[-]
But an alternate way to phrase that is that being in pain supplies you with a new, generally overriding goal: to get out of pain. Unless you think that, in general, acquiring new goals is bad, or that, in general, you shouldn't have goals that aren't maximally compatible with each other, I don't see what's necessarily bad about acquiring the goal "get out of pain" - unless you have an independent reason to think that the situation which yields that goal (pain) is bad.
Comment author:Tiiba
03 August 2009 12:43:04AM
0 points
[-]
Goals are for achieving. If a high-priority goal is hard to satisfy, my utility function returns a low number.
My answer to the main question: pain does an important job, but there are better ways to do it. Heck, pain can even hinder the goal of getting out of pain, it's so bad.
Comments (195)
But an alternate way to phrase that is that being in pain supplies you with a new, generally overriding goal: to get out of pain. Unless you think that, in general, acquiring new goals is bad, or that, in general, you shouldn't have goals that aren't maximally compatible with each other, I don't see what's necessarily bad about acquiring the goal "get out of pain" - unless you have an independent reason to think that the situation which yields that goal (pain) is bad.
Goals are for achieving. If a high-priority goal is hard to satisfy, my utility function returns a low number.
My answer to the main question: pain does an important job, but there are better ways to do it. Heck, pain can even hinder the goal of getting out of pain, it's so bad.