If only Eric had had a better response to this:
"What you're saying is tantamount to saying that you want to fuck me. So why shouldn't I react with revulsion precisely as though you'd said the latter?"
then maybe tragedy would have been averted?
I didn't suggest saying this out of the blue! My recommended riposte borrows the story protagonist's vocabulary and tone.
I understood that much the first time.
...If a woman asks you:
"What you're saying is tantamount to saying that you want to fuck me. So why shouldn't I react with revulsion precisely as though you'd said the latter?"
then, it may be appropriate to discuss, optionally using the word "fuck", why she'd react that way if you'd asked that question, which you didn't, having instead (as in the story) made a much more innocuous suggestion
Poignant short story about truth-seeking that I just found. Quote:
The full thing reads like a flash tour of OB/LW, except it was written in 2001.