SilasBarta comments on The Anthropic Trilemma - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (218)
What about if evolution repurposed some genus's tail to function as a leg? The question wouldn't be so juvenile or academic then. And before you roll your eyes, I can imagine someone saying,
"How many limbs does a mammal have, if you count the nose as a limb? Four. Calling a nose a limb doesn't make it one."
And then realizing they forgot about elephants, whose trunks have muscles that allow it to grip things as if it had a hand.
That looks like category reevaluation, not code-making, to me. If you think an elephant's trunk should be called a limb, and you think that elephants have five limbs, that's category reevaluation; if you think that elephant trunks should be called limbs and elephants have one limb, that's code.