Comment on December 2009 Meta Thread

Fri, 18 Dec 2009 05:01:23 GMT

So, yes, I've stuck my own opinions into it, and this is probably a pretty conservative list. Discuss.

I'm nonplussed. This is, as more or less described, a formalisation of your intuitive reaction to various posts. I don't share your intuitions regarding off topicness and, in particular, the 'please come and volunteer for us' example is on topic by my standards. Since formalising which posts are on topic doesn't seem particularly vital to me I reject your proposal to the extent that it seeks to embody your preferences into a general norm.

Discuss