army1987 comments on The Correct Contrarian Cluster - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (228)
I've read that in the 19th century, there were many people who said that iron ships couldn't possibly float. If you take a few seconds to do the math, you can quickly verify that iron ships can float. That seems like a good slam-dunk to me. Is there a modern equivalent?
Some similar, not-quite-as-obvious former popular opinions:
(Interestingly, the much older "sailboats can never sail upwind" seems more plausible to me than any of these.)
Contemporary unpopular slam-dunk-yes views:
There are culture-specific slam-dunks. I noticed, while traveling in China, particularly during an episode when the US bombed a Chinese embassy and when discussing the Tienanmen Square massacre, that most of the Chinese people who spoke openly with me (just a few) simultaneously believe their government is corrupt and untrustworthy, yet believed everything it said about those incidents. Numerous Russians I've spoken to have a blindness reconciling their views on Stalin with their views on Putin (the same attributes that made Stalin bad make Putin good). Maybe a foreigner should help us identify our slam-dunks.
There are some slam-dunks that are popular on the low end of g, and on the high end of g, but not in the middle range of g, e.g.
Using these in your survey could contaminate the results.
Who would dispute that? For starters, about 90% of men are more sexually attracted to females than to males, but only about 10% of women are.