Also, 2-boxing is indicated by inductive logic based on non-Omega situations. Given the special circumstances of Newcomb's problem, it would seem unwise to rely on that. Deductive logic leads to 1-boxing.

I agree that in general this is how it works. It's rather like POAT that way... some people see it as one kind of problem, and other people see it as another kind of problem, and neither side can make sense of the other's position.