MrHen comments on Epistemic Luck - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (132)
Can you think of another behavior pattern that is more accurate than this?
Assuming that someone isn't going to hold a belief they know to be false, they are teaching you perceived truth. Why wouldn't you adapt those beliefs? If you, the student, possessed the ability to denounce those beliefs in a manner fitting rational discussion it seems likely that the master would have been able to do so as well.
This isn't to say all masters are all right all the time, but what else do we have to go on until we go into the territory ourselves? These people went ahead and brought back a map. Different trailblazers saw the territory differently and now they get to bicker about which has a more accurate map.
When learning from people, I assume we copy portions from their map. They are lined up next to my discoveries and observations and are assimilated as best as possible. At some point, when I wander through that territory, I get to compare my map to what I see.
Am I wrong or missing something? Or is that the whole point of the post? Or... ?
Emphasis mine. I don't see how the emphasized part is a bias issue. I don't see how thinking about how a certain area of your map was colored causes the weird epistemic situation. I think the problem is this:
A predictor is right or wrong. Your teachers are irrelevant once the belief is in your map. Treating beliefs transported from a teacher as a lucky event has a few problems:
But all of this seems obvious and you address these points elsewhere in your post.
So perhaps you are saying that once you believe something, it becomes entrenched and now has an unfair advantage? I certainly understand this. As far as I can tell, this is one of the problems that rationality was supposed to address. Is the teacher scenario merely a special case?