Matt_Simpson comments on Hayekian Prediction Markets? - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (79)
I'm no Hayek scholar, but this looks like a straw man.
First of all:
Straight from Hayek's seminal article:
So by "central economic planning" Hayek means... the government planning all economic activity.
This is what I take Hayek's main points to be (largely from reading The Use of Knowledge in Society, linked above)
That's pretty much it, at least that relates to this discussion. Yes, this means there are diseconomies of scale. No this doesn't mean that there aren't economies of scale that are large enough to counter the diseconomies.
note that on my reading, your point about Wal-Mart is a point in Hayek's favor. Wal-Mart, though large, is part of a larger market.
btw, I won't vouch for those who think Hayek justifies extreme libertarianism. He doesn't. But he does rule out central planning ala The Soviet Union.