Peter_de_Blanc comments on Hedging our Bets: The Case for Pursuing Whole Brain Emulation to Safeguard Humanity's Future - Less Wrong

11 Post author: inklesspen 01 March 2010 02:32AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (244)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: Peter_de_Blanc 01 March 2010 07:14:40AM 2 points [-]

How does a lobster simulation transcend?

Comment author: gwern 01 March 2010 02:48:30PM 4 points [-]

Clearly people in this thread are not Charles Stross fans.

Comment author: JenniferRM 15 March 2010 04:43:55AM *  1 point [-]

For those not getting this, the book Accelerando starts with the main character being called by something with a russian accent that claims to be a neuromorphic AI based off of lobsters grafted into some knowledge management. This AI (roughly "the lobsters") seeks a human who can help them "defect".

I recommend the book! The ideas aren't super deep in retrospect but its "near future" parts have one hilariously juxtaposed geeky allusion after another and the later parts are an interesting take on post-human politics and economics.

I assume the lobsters were chosen because of existing research in this area. For example, there are techniques for keeping bits alive in vitro, there is modeling work from the 1990's trying to reproduce known neural mechanisms in silico, and I remember (but couldn't find the link) that a team had some success around 2001(?) doing a moravec transfer to one or more cells in a lobster ganglia (minus the nanotech of course). There are lots of papers in this area. The ones I linked to were easy to find.

Comment author: dclayh 01 March 2010 07:19:59AM 4 points [-]

That sounds like a koan.

Comment author: Mitchell_Porter 01 March 2010 07:40:33AM 0 points [-]

Someone uses it to explore its own fitness landscape.

Comment author: cousin_it 01 March 2010 01:43:30PM *  3 points [-]

Huh? Lobsters have been exploring their own fitness landscape for quite some time and haven't transcended yet. Evolution doesn't inevitably lead towards intelligence.

Comment author: Mitchell_Porter 02 March 2010 01:57:33AM 1 point [-]

I was way too obscure. I meant: turn it into a Godel machine by modifying the lobster program to explore and evaluate the space of altered lobster programs.

Comment author: cousin_it 08 March 2010 07:07:07PM *  1 point [-]

Why do you need a lobster for that? You could start today with any old piece of open source code and any measure of "fitness" you like. People have tried to do this for awhile without much success.