knb comments on The Importance of Goodhart's Law - Less Wrong

75 Post author: blogospheroid 13 March 2010 08:19AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (112)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: James_K 13 March 2010 10:28:33PM 9 points [-]

The Soviet Union killed tens of millions of its people through work camps, starvation and purges. How is that not a disaster?

And GDP is not hard to game if you're centrally planning the economy. And even that excludes simply lying about your figures.

Comment author: knb 14 March 2010 07:54:54AM 8 points [-]

The Soviet Union killed tens of millions of its people through work camps, starvation and purges. How is that not a disaster?

This is a really good point. It kind of goes to the heart of the emptiness of GDP as a statistic. What was the death toll of a 5% increase in GDP? The Soviet economy also was infamous for overproducing big capital goods but failing to produce consumer goods people actually wanted to buy.

Comment author: ggg 14 March 2010 09:30:27AM 9 points [-]

Similarly, Ceauşescu supposedly managed to clear Romania's national debt, but, in doing so, impoverished the people and crushed their spirit. The socio-cultural damage he did to the country cannot be overstated. (btw I'm half-Romanian and lived there during his reign).