Warrigal comments on Understanding your understanding - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (77)
Excellent post, I like the breakdown. So let's take a simple example for clarification:
"Why do race cars sound high-pitched when they are coming toward you and low pitched when they're heading away?"
Level 0: "That's because of the Doppler effect."
Level 1: "The frequency is f = (v + vr)/(v+vs) * f0 . Make sure you get the signs right."
Level 2: "Sound waves have a wavelength, but the wavelength is shortened when the car is coming toward you, because the car 'catches up' with its own waves, and lengthened when it's heading away. Since the waves travel at a constant speed in the medium, a short wavelength implies a high frequency, and frequency is what we hear as pitch. Yes, I know the equation. The phenomenon also happens for light, although the equation is different."
Level 3: "No, I don't remember the equation. Here, gimme a minute and I'll derive it."
So what do you call it when you know the level-2 explanation but don't know the equation and can't derive it?
Deriving the frequency equation. I should do that some time.
I'd call it "time to dust off the math books". Incidentally, I've got to do just that.