Nick_Tarleton comments on Blue- and Yellow-Tinted Choices - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (54)
Holy crap we're broken. Good info.
I'm a little worried that calling (a/i)rrational persuasive techniques "Dark Arts", even in seemingly indefensible (though, it must be said, minor) cases like this, biases us against them and will make people averse to using them even when doing so is ethical and beneficial. What do others think? Am I overreacting?
FWIW, I suspect most casual readers don't know about Methods of Rationality and were confused by this.
Well, they should fix that.
The label "Dark Arts" is itself an example of Dark Arts: romanticizing something to hide assumptions in it.
Yeah, but was this relevant? Shouldn't this go in an open thread or its own post?
Yes, you're right, it is probably too off topic. I replied to the above comment without too much thinking about the context. I'll delete it and cache the thought for a more appropriate moment.
That seems a bit extreme. Why not put it on the open thread now, even if you plan on elaborating later?
Don't worry, I can quickly reproduce the same argument whenever a more opportune context comes up.
I like the reference to "Dark Arts", but I've removed the Quirrell part on your suggestion.