SilasBarta comments on On Enjoying Disagreeable Company - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (243)
Whoa, when was evidence a pre-requisite for you to post strongly about something? Since two minutes ago?
I'm going to go out on a limb and guess that you put full credence in Alicorn's self-serving, unverifiable claim to having been diagnosed with Asberger's, despite her infamous, "Why not just meet women on the internet?" line ... am I right?
And yet the very basis for your criticism of me was that I'm making a non-NT-characteristic mistake in interpreting a social situation? Did your arguments come before or after your conclusion?
I, Lucas Sloan, do solemnly swear that Alicorn is not neurotypical, and very probably has Asperger's. I further attest that the information this comment is based on is the result of having physically interacted with her.
I'm not familiar with this “infamous” remark and I'm not sure what you're suggesting it proves or even implies. I recently read the book Born on a Blue Day, which was written by Daniel Tammet, a man with Asperger's. He writes at one point:
Tammet met his partner on the Internet. His reasoning makes sense to me. Is there something ridiculous that I am missing about the suggestion that people, especially those with autism spectrum diagnoses, meet other people on the Internet, as opposed to real life?
Of course. Just check out HughRistik's detailed explanation of how such a suggestion, like "let them eat cake" completely misunderstands the state of an AS male.
Yes, in some time and place it was possible for these internet chats to easily translate into dating for aspies, but apparently, everyone on the site seemed to disagree with Alicorn's assessment.
But taking it as a given that Alicorn's comment completely misunderstood the state of an AS male, how does it show that she also completely misunderstands the state of an AS female, and how does the comment therefore provide support for your suggestion that Alicorn's AS is in doubt because she made that comment?