red75 comments on A proposal for a cryogenic grave for cryonics - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (137)
Here's the point of divergence. There is peculiar coarse-graining. Specifically it is conceptual self-model consciousness uses to operate on (as a wrote earlier it uses concepts of self, mind, desire, intention, emotion, memory, feeling, etc. When I think "I want to know more", my consciousness uses concepts of that model to (crudely) represent actual state of (part of) brain including parts which represent model itself). Thus, to find a consciousness in a system it is necessary to find a coarse-graining such that corresponding macrostate of system is isomorphic to physical state of part of the system (it is not sufficient, however). Or in map-territory analogy to find a part of territory that isomorphic to a (crude) map of territory.
Edit: Well, it seems that lower bound on information content of map is necessary for this approach too. However, this approach doesn't require adding fundamental ontological concepts.
Edit: Isomorphism condition is too limiting, it will require another level of course-graining to be true. I'll try to come up with another definition.