Vladimir_Nesov comments on Open Thread: July 2010, Part 2 - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (770)
Geoff Greer published a post on how he got convinced to sign up for cryonics: Insert Frozen Food Joke Here.
If they think that we'll all eventually die even with cryonics and they think that death gives meaning to life then they don't need to worry about cryonics removing meaning since it is just pushing the amount of time until death up. (I wouldn't bother addressing the death giving meaning to life claim except to note that it seems to be a much more common meme among people who haven't actually lost loved ones.)
As to the problem of too many people, overpopulation is a massive problem whether or not a few people get cryonicly preserved.
As to the problem of just the rich getting the benefits, patiently explain that there's no reason to think that the rich now will be treated substantially different from the less rich who sign up for cryonics. And if society ever has the technology to easily revive people from cryonic suspension then the likely standard of living will be so high compared to now that even if the rich have more it won't matter.
I talk about it as something I'm thinking about, and ask what they think. That way, it's not you trying to persuade someone, it's just a conversation.
"Yeah, we'll all die eventually, but this is just a way of curing aging, just like trying to find a cure for heart disease or cancer. All those things are true of any medical treatment, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't save lives."
... "and like any medical treatment, initially only the rich will benefit, but they'll help bring down the price for everyone else. Infact, for just a small weakly payment..."
This is off-topic but I'm curious: How did you stumble on my blog?
Google alert on "Eliezer Yudkowsky". (Usually brings up articles about Friendly AI, SIAI and Less Wrong.)