But my theory is interesting; how can the supporting evidence not be true?!
Supporting evidence isn't what Alicorn contradicted. She contradicted your absolute claim (last thing...)
Surely 'Methods is the Rationality book' is the conclusion, and "If you're having trouble writing, the last thing you need is another book, competing for your attention" is the evidence?
ETA: There is now a third thread, so send new comments there.
Since the first thread has exceeded 500 comments, it seems time for a new one, with Eliezer's just-posted Chapter 33 & 34 to kick things off.
From previous post: