ewbrownv comments on Problems in evolutionary psychology - Less Wrong

55 Post author: Kaj_Sotala 13 August 2010 06:57PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (102)

You are viewing a single comment's thread.

Comment author: ewbrownv 13 August 2010 09:06:57PM 0 points [-]

Yes, we're all tired of hearing cousin Joe's transparent attempts to rationalize his personal prejudices by convincing himself that 'it's evolution'. And yes, as a general rule, in propositions of the form 'humans exhibit behavior X due to evolutionary explanation Y' the 'explanation Y' part provides very little evidence. But I can't help but notice that this makes a very convenient excuse to dismiss any observation you happen to be uncomfortable with, just because it comes packaged with an evolutionary explanation.

Since the whole topic of human behavior is bound to make people uncomfortable, this doesn't strike me as a winning strategy. Far better to admit that an evolutionary perspective can be a handy tool for identifying fruitful research topics and separating plausible vs. implausible hypothesis, even though the evolutionary explanation does not in and of itself qualify as evidence. Which, of course, is the approach that actual ev-psych researchers (as opposed to cocktail-lounge theorists) generally take.

Comment author: Kaj_Sotala 13 August 2010 09:16:23PM 4 points [-]

But I can't help but notice that this makes a very convenient excuse to dismiss any observation you happen to be uncomfortable with, just because it comes packaged with an evolutionary explanation.

Hardly. If I take an offered explanation for an observation with a grain of salt, that doesn't mean I can dismiss the observation itself. At most I can dismiss the explanation.

Far better to admit that an evolutionary perspective can be a handy tool for identifying fruitful research topics

Yes, that's what I was saying.

and separating plausible vs. implausible hypothesis

Evolutionary psychology is likely to also help with this, yes, though we need to be careful with it and remember what we don't know.