Here's a somewhat rough way of estimating probabilities of unlikely events. Let's say that an event X with P(X) = about 1-in-10 is a "lucky break." Suppose that there are L(1) ways that Y could occur on account of a single lucky break, L(2) ways that Y could occur on account of a pair of independent lucky breaks, L(3) ways that Y could occur on account of 3 independent lucky breaks, and so on. Then P(Y) is approximately the sum over all n of L(n)/10^n. I have the feeling that arguments about whether P(Y) is small versus extremely small are arguments about the growth rate of L(n).

I discussed the problem of estimating P("23% of humanity believes...") here. I'd be grateful for thoughts or criticisms.