mattnewport comments on Dealing with the high quantity of scientific error in medicine - Less Wrong

36 Post author: NancyLebovitz 25 October 2010 01:53PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (55)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: NancyLebovitz 27 October 2010 10:58:23PM *  2 points [-]

If it won't complicate your social life too much here, I'm quite curious about your ideas on diet-- and if you don't want to make them public to LW, could you PM me?

The "textbook stomach" compared to the range of actual stomachs.

I saw that chart a long time ago in an article in a vegetarian magazine. The article said that about 10% of the people who try vegetarianism don't thrive on it. It also said that no one needs more than 4 oz. of meat per day to be healthy.l

A little more about variation-- I've talked with a man who keeps records of his blood tests based on the hope that rejuvenation may be possible, and the theory that if it is, it will be very useful to know what blood chemistry details should be used as a target-- some blood factors (sorry, I didn't ask which ones) vary by a factor of ten among healthy people.

Comment author: Craig_Heldreth 28 October 2010 12:32:24AM 1 point [-]

I find the paleo argument pretty compelling by virtue of the logic of the argument--i.e. homo sapiens evolved in an environment which did not have agriculture and grains. Also there is an M.D. blogger whose name escapes me who strongly advises people to avoid all processed grains because they pulse the glucose-insulin cycle in the blood. In March I overhauled my diet. I was eating a croissant every morning, two slices of bread every noon, and two to four cookies every evening. My grain consumption is now less than three slices of bread every four days. I eat cheese and yogurt. So I am not paleo. I do eat a serving of fruit and a serving of raw nuts at every meal.

I may be the most paleo person I know.

The other overhaul I did to my diet is the largest mass of food I am now taking in daily is a big plate of frozen vegetables at noon. I buy the two pound sacks of: 1) peas; 2) corn; 3) string beans; 4) broccoli and cauliflower mix; 5) peas and corn and carrots and string beans and lima beans mix. Choosing which of the sacks to pour from at noon is one of the high points in my typical day. My weight is down; my body mass index is down; my workouts have more pep. I am going to be hanging with this diet for a while.

I like Pollan's formula: eat food, not too much, mostly plants. If somebody put that in the rationality quote thread I would upvote it. Beyond his formula, I do not like Pollan at all. He is not a nutritionist; he is a journalist. When I try and read any of his writing at length my eyes roll.

The best partisan of the paleo philosophy in my mind is the anthropologist David Abram who is part of the "re-wilding movement". I am not anywhere close to a re-wilding movement partisan, but his discussions of forager cultures and what those folks may have to teach us makes Michael Pollan and most of the other more popular figures look like they are serving up extremely thin gruel.

Normal testosterone in males varies by a factor of almost 4:241-827 ng/dL. This sticks in my memory because the last time my doctor did my blood I was at the top of the normal range and I asked him how come I don't look like a gorilla. (The 241-827 does not stick in my memory--I looked it up.) I think my doctor is awesome but his answer to that question was not.

Your textbook stomach link is truly a picture worth a thousand words.

Comment author: mattnewport 28 October 2010 12:56:35AM *  0 points [-]

Paleo diets generally consider corn a grain so you might want to avoid that. Some paleo variants (like the one I'm currently following) are ok with cheese and yogurt in moderation (and butter).