ata comments on If reductionism is the hammer, what nails are out there? - Less Wrong

14 Post author: AnnaSalamon 11 December 2010 01:58PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (46)

You are viewing a single comment's thread.

Comment author: ata 11 December 2010 10:49:37PM 7 points [-]

For example, I had lunch the other day with a physics professor from a good university who thought that, even if we could assemble an atom-for-atom duplicate of a person's exact physical state, it might well not act like a person for want of a soul.

...a PHYSICS PROFESSOR??

That makes my head hurt.

And that makes me realize that, after all this time reading LW and OB, I must still be overestimating academia. Consider me updated.

Comment author: JGWeissman 11 December 2010 11:20:57PM 4 points [-]

The physics professors who taught me quantum mechanics seemed to believe there is something special making up the human mind that, unlike all other matter in the universe, cannot be put int a superposition, and thus causes the wave function to collapse to one of its component eigen states. I won't say that it doesn't bother me that some of them believe in souls, but I've gotten used to it.

Comment author: jimmy 12 December 2010 06:33:43AM 3 points [-]

The physics professor that taught me quantum mechanics not only thought 'collapse' was some wonderfully mysterious phenomenon, the fact that the most probable location to find an electron can be at r = 0, while the most probable radius is non zero was wonderfully mysterious to him.

Comment author: multifoliaterose 13 December 2010 03:17:28AM *  2 points [-]

It's important to understand that there's likely strong compartmentalization going on here. Having such beliefs is not mutually exclusive with being a strong scientific researcher. Such indications should not be read as overly strong indications of low levels of general competence.