rhollerith_dot_com comments on Draft/wiki: Infinities and measuring infinite sets: A quick reference - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (24)
Blorst horst.
I would like it if you paired each "myth" line with an explicit "truth" line that gave the tl;dr for us, maybe even using simple language e.g.
Myth: The cardinalities of infinite sets can be compared like ordinary numbers. Reality: If the axiom of choice is false, you can have one set's cardinality be both larger and smaller than another's
(maybe even a short blurb explaining the axiom of choice's role)
I could still understand you, but it certainly helped that I'd borrowed my friend's topology book over the summer.
Rather than making a big list, some more structure and an actual conclusion to topic #1 would have helped cement things in my brain.
Since this turned out pretty long, you could actually split the topics into separate posts in a series. And with a little editing I would be all for these being top-level posts rather than discussion secion.
I would have gone the other way and abandoned the attempt to arrange things in a list. I.e., I would have made the structure simpler, e.g., sections divided into paragraphs, e.g., no attempt to number anything.