Thomas comments on New Year's Predictions Thread (2011) - Less Wrong

10 Post author: Kevin 02 January 2011 09:58AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (224)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: JoshuaZ 02 January 2011 02:46:52PM 4 points [-]

General AI will not be made in 2011. Confidence: 90%.

The removal of DADT by the US military will result in fewer than 300 soldiers leaving the military in protest. (Note that this may be hard to measure.) Confidence: 95%.

The Riemann Hypothesis will not be proven. Confidence: 75%. (Minor note for the nitpickers: relevant foundational system is ZFC.)

Ryan Williams recent bound on ACC circuits of NEXP ((See here for a discussion of Williams work)) will be tightened in at least one of three ways: The result will be shown to apply for some smaller set of problems than NEXP, the result will be improved for some broader type of circuit than ACC, or the bound on the circuit size ruled out will be improved. Confidence: 60%

At least one head pastor of a Protestant megachurch in the US will be found to be engaging in homosexual activity. For purposes of this prediction "megachurch" means a church with regular attendance of 3000 people at Sunday services. Confidence: 70%.

Clashes between North Korea and South Korea will result in fatalities: Confidence 80%.

Comment author: Thomas 02 January 2011 05:11:31PM 2 points [-]

General AI will not be made in 2011. Confidence: 90%.

I like this. In other words it's over 70% that AGI will be invented before 2020.

Comment author: JoshuaZ 02 January 2011 05:18:56PM 8 points [-]

No. That calculation assumes independent probabilities for each year.

Comment author: Thomas 02 January 2011 05:52:11PM -2 points [-]

So, it's not the prediction for the next year only, but for a longer period.

Interesting.

Comment author: Will_Sawin 02 January 2011 10:01:36PM 9 points [-]

No. One model that could produce that prediction for next year is that one is 89% confident that GAI is impossible, and 90% confident that if possible, it will be discovered next year. Strange beliefs, yes.

But they give 10% chance this year and 11% in the next ten.