Mass_Driver comments on Rationalist Clue - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (23)
Spot on, all all counts. There are other ideas that just got posted that might help with this; if players had a limited number of chips and were playing to maximize their chip count, then sharing info would only make sense if you thought it would give you a relative advantage. If the murderer was given weak evidence that he/she was the murderer, that might create a bit of deception without encouraging a Mafia dynamic. Accusations could be made expensive relative to other activities (i.e., you have to go to the Control Room, or gather everybody together, etc.).
I had imagined that you can talk whenever your characters are in the same room, but you can't ever physically flip over your clue cards to show people what they say. E.g. if you did an autopsy on the left leg and it revealed lead-pipe-impacts, you could say "It was a lead pipe, I swear!" but you couldn't actually give the person your "lead-pipe-impact" card. Just like in real life, we don't have provably-secure mind-bridges. You could, however, give the person the left leg, and then they could do their own autopsy.
I agree, and I'll find ways to avoid that risk. It happens to be one of my talents.
Thank you! I'm glad you think so.