taryneast comments on Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality discussion thread, part 7 - Less Wrong

7 Post author: Unnamed 14 January 2011 06:49AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (495)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: Acrinoe 27 January 2011 12:15:05AM 5 points [-]

Two Questions/Guesses

1) Prof. Quirrell pointed out that Harry was especially vulnerable to the "Finite Incantatem" spell (to removed his transfigured armor). How does the canon mechanics of this spell work from a tactical standpoint? Is it area of effect or targeted on a per spell basis? Can a weak 1st year dispel a casting done by Headmaster Dumbledor or does caster strength play a role in its effectivity? Depending on the answers, Harry's vulnerability could be mitigated by pure strength or recursive spell depth or minor covering spells to absorb the dispelling castings. 'Just saying. :)

2) In terms of world building, I wonder if Harry is considering that he's got good evidence of living in a "matrix style" simulation with the reality glitches that is the existence of magic. It seems to me like just so many reality "cheat codes", hence Harry's inability to derive underlying principles in the operation and physics of magic. Indeed, the whole hero/quest/prophecy shtick would also count heavily towards a simulation argument.

Comment author: taryneast 30 January 2011 10:29:53AM 6 points [-]

I wonder if Harry is considering that he's got good evidence of living in a "matrix style" simulation

He already tried on "computer simulation" - but discarded it when he found out how the time-turner worked.

I'm personally wondering when Harry figures out that he's actually a fictional character :)

Comment author: [deleted] 07 February 2011 07:45:39AM *  4 points [-]

I'm personally wondering when Harry figures out that he's actually a fictional character :)

While it might be a bit too mind-screwy for MoR, I can't help but to think that it would be amazing if, say, Harry confronted Eliezer on allowing Azkaban to exist within his universe just so that the latter could have an interesting and important location to use in his story. Something like Non-Player Character. Omake opportunity, perhaps?

Comment author: Broggly 30 April 2011 10:07:48AM 4 points [-]

The obvious response is to include in the trigger warning a statement for any sufficiently advanced intelligence or humans with philosophical reservations about imagining other conscious beings that the story includes suffering, descriptions of suffering, and people reflecting on the suffering of others in detail.

Comment author: taryneast 07 February 2011 10:34:59AM 0 points [-]

Awesome idea. :)

Comment author: TobyBartels 05 February 2011 11:34:16AM 1 point [-]

He already tried on "computer simulation" - but discarded it when he found out how the time-turner worked.

And discarded it without good reason.

Comment author: major 30 January 2011 12:33:15PM 0 points [-]

I think Ch21 (near the end) played with this idea already. How many potential first week has Eliezer thought through before settling on that one, I wonder.