Desrtopa comments on Subjective Relativity, Time Dilation and Divergence - Less Wrong

14 Post author: jacob_cannell 11 February 2011 07:50AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (95)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: Desrtopa 12 February 2011 09:52:29PM 0 points [-]

What if Moore's Law type inward exponential expansion has no limit? There doesn't appear to be any real hard limit on the energy cost of computation.

The entire scenario of this post rests on this "what if," and it's not a very probable one. There appear to be hard theoretical limits to the speed of computation and the amount of computation that can be performed with a given amount of energy, and there may easily be practical limitations which set the bounds considerably lower. Assuming that there are limits is the default position, and in an intelligence explosion, it's quite likely that the AI will reach those limits quite quickly, unless the resources available on Earth alone do not allow for it.

Comment author: jacob_cannell 12 February 2011 10:31:15PM *  0 points [-]

That wiki entry is wrong and or out of date. It only considers strictly classical irreversible computation. It doesn't mention quantum and reversible computation.

But as to the larger question - yes I think there are probably eventual limits, but even this can not yet be said for certain until we have a complete unified theory of physics: quantum gravity and what not.

From what we do understand of current physics, the limits of computation take us down to singularities, regions of space time similar to the big bang: black holes, wormholes, etc type objects, which are not fully understood in current physics.

Also, the larger trend towards greater complexity is not really dependent on computational growth per se. At the higher level of abstraction, the computational resources of the earth haven't changed much since it's formation. All of the complexity increase since then has been various forms of reorganization of matter/energy patterns. Increasing computational density is just one form of complexity increasing transformation. Complexity can continue to increase at many other levels of organization (software, mental, knowledge, organizational, meta, etc)

So the more important general question is this: is there an absolute final limit to the future complexity of the earth system? And if we reach that, what happens next?

Comment author: Desrtopa 12 February 2011 10:34:44PM 0 points [-]

Can you explain what this complexity is and why you want so much of it?

Comment author: jacob_cannell 12 February 2011 10:49:29PM 0 points [-]

See my other recent reply on our other thread.