Vladimir_Nesov comments on The Neuroscience of Desire - Less Wrong

54 Post author: lukeprog 09 April 2011 07:08PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (30)

You are viewing a single comment's thread.

Comment author: Vladimir_Nesov 10 April 2011 01:13:11PM *  14 points [-]

This post is too short for the amount of knowledge it seeks to refer. It does little more than list the references associated with terse and vague-to-the-reader hints about their topic and interrelation. It looks more like an obligatory survey section of a paper that ought to include a survey section to position itself in the context of a field and less like an introductory survey of survey articles that I expect it was intended as being.

I can only see it being useful for a reader who would follow it by digging into the referenced papers. A good cause, but it feels like there was more low-hanging fruit potential for exposition resulting from your study of these topics.

Comment author: lukeprog 10 April 2011 03:14:36PM 12 points [-]

We may have different ideas about how much knowledge I'm trying to refer.

I'm not hoping that people come away from this article with a good understanding of how the primate brain calculates value and uses this data in decision-making. I'm merely hoping to explain that we do actually seem to be doing something like maximizing subjective expected utility - much to the surprise even of economists - and that neuroscientists know a great deal about how this works.

If you want the full story, you need to read a book. I've recommended several.