I agree it's a complicated issue (I am resistant to the notion of considering "anemic" as 'offensive', but...?). I simply wanted to point out that Constant's criticism was insufficient.
So far the only offensive term you've been able to come up with that does not violate your general idea is "bad" - i.e., a pure, non-descriptive value judgment. In short, what you have argued - interpreting your somewhat ambiguous statement in the light of your examples - is that value judgment terms are okay only so long as they carry not a shred of description. Once they gain a descriptive dimension, then they are ruled out. What you wrote is somewhat ambiguous but your example supports this interpretation. The only acceptable word is "bad...
We're excited to have a second Phoenix meetup. As always, absolutely anyone is welcome. This time we'd like to change the location to the Barrett Honors College Dining Hall at ASU (It's extremely nice and has excellent food). I'll be there from 5 to 7 on Saturday and have a copy of Godel, Escher, Bach on the table.
The address is 698-798 Apache Blvd E, Tempe, AZ, and here it is on a map. The parking garage on Lemon is probably ideal, Barrett is south of that.
My phone number is 602-501-9420, feel free to call or text me.