Ooo! Good advice is good! Thanks!
Pick one
Pick at random
I do that for decisions that don't matter much (e.g. picking a movie). It's more problematic when I know I will regret picking the wrong one badly.
Wait for a good feeling
Good idea, thanks. Does this work in reverse, with a bad feeling about all other options?
Ask someone else
I do that as much as possible, but it fails more often that not. Polite bastards.
Ask a model of someone else/myself
Predict myself
Seek variety
All good ideas, thanks a lot! (Though variety-seeking contradicts the others, and conflicting rules are Bad.)
Might be helpful to set up meta-rules. In any given situation, a hierarchy of which rules apply, or which to fall back on if the main ones are inconclusive. For example, variety-seeking could be one of the low-ranked options, seldom used but still significant for it's tendency to shake up the results of other rules.
Y'all know the rules: