hairyfigment comments on Scientific misconduct misdiagnosed because of scientific misconduct - Less Wrong

44 Post author: GLaDOS 10 June 2011 02:49PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (54)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: hairyfigment 10 June 2011 08:05:12PM *  -1 points [-]

See now, this layman couldn't tell from Wikipedia why Edwards' critique actually contradicts what the intro calls the main point of Lewontin. Edit: I mean the section on Lewontin's argument.

It would seem very odd if a sufficiently knowledgeable geneticist couldn't tell a person's natural skin color from their genes with near 100% reliability. Melanin clearly has a strong genetic component, as do other physical features that correlate with melanin. We want to know if it correlates with any interesting genetic differences.

Comment author: timtyler 11 June 2011 01:27:01PM 6 points [-]

Melanin clearly has a strong genetic component, as do other physical features that correlate with melanin. We want to know if it correlates with any interesting genetic differences.

Well, rather obviously it correlates with all sorts of things: not having red hair, or blue eyes, or blond hair, or straight hair, not being an Ashkenazi Jew, and not being able to digest milk. What would you find "interesting", though?