Peterdjones comments on How not to move the goalposts - Less Wrong

4 Post author: HopeFox 12 June 2011 03:45PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (71)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: Perplexed 12 June 2011 04:52:11PM 25 points [-]

Good choice of topic, but ...

Unfortunately, most of the arguments I could choose for this discussion are either highly trivial or highly controversial. I'll choose one that I hope won't cause too much trouble.

I think it may be the worst possible choice. First, for suggesting that the question of compensation for engineers should be approached as a moral issue. Second, for failing to make the point that differences (between the sexes) in engineering aptitude in the general population says nothing about differences in engineering skill among people who have already been hired as engineers. Third, because gender differences between groups say little about differences between individuals. Fourth, because gender is a problematic subject in this forum, even when you do everything right.

I also second Nesov's cringe at the implicit conflation of unpleasant and suitable-to-be-disagreed-with.

Comment author: Peterdjones 12 June 2011 05:51:32PM 3 points [-]

Upvoted for for being an accurate diagnosis of the problems in the original posting.