timtyler comments on Model Uncertainty, Pascalian Reasoning and Utilitarianism - Less Wrong

23 Post author: multifoliaterose 14 June 2011 03:19AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (154)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: timtyler 16 June 2011 06:29:29PM *  0 points [-]

As for the implied idea that natural selection does not apply to memes, I'll try to bite my tongue there.

That totally wasn't what I meant to imply.

's why I tried to bite my tongue - but it was difficult to completely let it go by...

For someone like me it is pretty accurate to say that I got my utility function from natural selection acting on DNA genes.

Yes, but I think you're rather unusual in this regard; most people aren't so wary of memes. Might I ask why you prefer genes to memes? This seems odd to me.

Well, I love memes, but DNA-genes built 99% of my ancestors unassisted, and are mostly responsible for building me. They apparently equipped me with a memetic immune system, for weeding out undesirable memes, to allow me to defend myself in those cases where there is a conflict of interests.

Why should I side with the memes? They aren't even related to me. The best of them are beneficial human symbionts - rather like lettuces and strawberries. I care for them some - but don't exactly embrace their optimisation targets as my own.

I don't dispute memes have done a lot of good things in the world. So has Mother Teresa - but that doesn't mean I have to adopt her goals as my own either.