taryneast comments on Ego syntonic thoughts and values - Less Wrong

53 Post author: Yvain 17 July 2011 08:43PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (53)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: [deleted] 01 August 2011 05:26:16PM 1 point [-]

I had considered this. Further evidence: I have an atypical reaction to coffee. I get sleepy, then really calm. I react to very small doses and don't seem to build resistance (except to the anti-tiredness property). This is not unusual for manics and ADD folk. Both my parents drink coffee right before going to bed, to sleep better. (I don't, normally. Sleep quality goes way up, but caffeine also disrupts it, so memory suffers.)

But going with "alright, I'm bipolar" is just a label. I've gone through enough of those already.

As far as I know, there's no good bipolar treatment. Lithium might be useful for more major cases, but my general mood is fairly stable as is. Inspired by Seth Roberts, I experimented with morning faces, movement and sunlight. Light therapy seems to stabilize my depression (though it's too early to tell; winter is coming). The other two do nothing.

Besides the stuff I already listened, I'm not aware of any other promising treatment. I have a fairly low opinion of therapists, so I haven't made a great effort to check them out. I studied all plausible methods though, often with neat successes, but unfortunately only for different problems.

(Don't take this as negative dismissal. It's just that so far I haven't been successful down this road. Right now, I suspect that working on the level of thought or mood is useless as that's not were the issue is. I'm trying to escalate the problem now to get a better picture of what exactly isn't working, so I'm actively seeking out boredom, pain, guilt and so on. That's certainly an atypical approach. I don't know if it is successful or sane, but when you can't find a bug, it always helps to have more data about what input causes it break...)

Comment author: taryneast 02 August 2011 09:04:18AM *  0 points [-]

Lithium is a treatment that does not work on everybody. It is, in fact, the oldest of the known treatments, and the newer treatments are different and work with different people.

I have a bipolar (type 2) family member - who went through lithium and two other treatments before settling on seroquel. The best use of a "therapist" in this case is somebody that has great experience with what drugs are appropriate and what level you should be taking them at. After all, it's always possible that lithium is your drug, but you were using the wrong dosage...

As to the other forms of treatment you've mentioned. These are emphatically not treatments for bipolar disorder. They are treatments for seasonal affective disorder (ie lack of sufficient light during the darker months causing emotional imbalance). Bipolar mood-swings occur regardless of light-levels.