We do see theologians try to respond to these sorts of issues. Look at the many attempts to deal with {fate, free will, existence of evil, God's omniscience,God's omnipotence, God's omnibenevolence}. We don't get deep controversies. Instead we get theologians competing with how sophisticated they can make arguments to try to have their cake and eat it too. Meanwhile in almost any tribe(whether united by religion, politics or something else), the vast majority of members go about their days without giving any serious thought to whether any of their tribes standard beliefs contradict each other.