Ahhh, you're meaning "we have Bayesian evidence that Person B is less likely to be rational than Person A"?
Yeah I should have been more explicit on that, sorry for the miscommunication!
I'd agree, but I still think it's weak evidence if you're only looking at a single situation, and
I'd still feel I therefore know more about Person A (how they handle these situations) than I do about Person B (merely that they are either ignorant or irrational). How someone handles a situation strikes me as a more consistent trait, whereas most people seem to have enough gaps in their knowledge that a single gap is very little evidence for other gaps.
Perhaps for convenience we can add that person A and B are exposed to the same information? It dosen't change the spirit of the thought experiment. I was originally implicitly operating with that as given but since we started discussing it I've noticed I never explicitly mentioned it.
Basically I wanted to compare what kinds of things person A/B would signal in a certain set of circumstances to others.
Yeah I should have been more explicit on that, sorry for the miscommunication!
No worries. I think part of it was on me as well :)
This is thread where I'm trying to figure out a few things about signalling on LessWrong and need some information, so please immediately after reading about the two individuals please answer the poll. The two individuals:
A. Sees that an interpretation of reality shared by others is not correct, but tries to pretend otherwise for personal gain and/or safety.
B. Fails to see that an interpretation of reality is shared by others is flawed. He is therefore perfectly honest in sharing the interpretation of reality with others. The reward regime for outward behaviour is the same as with A.
To add a trivial inconvenience that matches the inconvenience of answering the poll before reading on, comments on what I think the two individuals signal,what the trade off is and what I speculate the results might be here versus the general population, is behind this link.