Paul Graham's essay "Why Nerds are Unpopular" has been mentioned a few times on LW, in a very positive way.
My initial reaction upon reading that essay a couple years ago was also very positive. However, upon rereading it, I realized it doesn't really fit with my observations or what I know from social science research at all. I want to write a top level post about why I disagree with Graham, but I'm not really sure if that would be on-topic enough for a top-level.
So I guess I'll just put this to a vote. Please upvote this if you think I should write a top-level post.
Why not just do a draft in discussion? It's a top level subject, but how could we judge well at this point without knowing what the post would look like?
If it's worth saying, but not worth its own post (even in Discussion), then it goes here.
If continuing the discussion becomes impractical, that means you win at open threads; a celebratory top-level post on the topic is traditional.