I think our current culture tends to push people into a certainty that they may not be inclined to
People don't necessarily just have one degree of certainty they're naturally inclined to. I do not think it is culture making people feel more sure than they think they should be. This was recent and relevant.
"Religious Belief Systems of Persons with High Functioning Autism":
Caldwell-Harris et al 2011.
Mostly as one would expect, although I am troubled that the second survey did not find any difference in agnostics, only the other categories.
See also: "How to be deader than dead".