Kaj_Sotala comments on [paper draft] Coalescing minds: brain uploading-related group mind scenarios - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (20)
Would sensory prosthetics be the kind of thing you're looking for? I can add some cites about those.
I don't think that this has been done.
I'm unsure about the answers to these, though they seem to me like problems that could be eventually overcome. I'll see if my coauthor has a comment - the neuroscience part was his domain of expertise, not mine.
Are you asking about a (natural brain)-(exocortex) merge, or a (natural brain & exocortex)-(another natural brain & exocortex) merge?
If there were enough connections between the exocortex and the natural brain, then yes, given enough time the exocortex would probably merge with the natural brain so as to become pretty completely a part of it. An uncontrollable rate seems to me unlikely - it takes a long time for a child's brain to develop to a mature state, and a large part of that development presumably involves various parts of the brain integrating with each other better - but again, the neuroscience side is not my domain of top expertise, so I might be mistaken about that.
As for one exocortex-equipped brain integrating with another, the extent to which that can happen obviously depends on the amount of connections / bandwidth available, and on whether the connections are maintained constantly or only for short periods.
Good point. It was supposed to note that coalescence can be achieved by first "traditionally" uploading a mind and then directly creating connections between the emulated brains, or by an exocortex route. I'll clarify that or change the title.
Yes, they complement this nicely.
Well, destructive uploading as a whole seems to be a problem that could be eventually overcome, so with this approach you could discuss the upload-first scenario before the neurological one.
About dynamics of distinct-brain merge via exocortices - maybe you could mention what existing knowledge and what possible experiments could help answering these questions in the article.