RobertLumley comments on Rationality Quotes October 2011 - Less Wrong

3 Post author: MinibearRex 03 October 2011 06:41AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (532)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: RobertLumley 03 October 2011 04:36:00PM 3 points [-]

I'm very confused by the downvotes, could someone explain?

Comment author: Desrtopa 03 October 2011 07:55:38PM 8 points [-]

First off, it's easy to cheer "yay science!" and rag on low status beliefs, but does this quote tell us that this person is good at determining truth value in cases of controversy? If an experiment returns a particular result, do they feel compelled to believe it? What would they think, for example, about the OPERA measurements?

Second, a cheer for the epistemic rationality of engineers is particular is likely to be unpopular because engineers are somewhat famous for standing on the frontiers of crank science, and have a reputation for being more likely than others with "scientific" backgrounds to overestimate their own understanding and throw their credentials behind bad science.

Comment author: RobertLumley 03 October 2011 08:13:04PM 2 points [-]

This is in fact, what the other person I mentioned commented, which I agree with, in retrospect. I had the advantage of context though - the author didn't specifically mean to laud engineers - this statement was made in the context of an engineering ethics textbook (essay? It's hard to remember, it was awhile ago).

Comment author: Document 03 October 2011 07:00:41PM *  4 points [-]

Didn't downvote, but:

  • Is he advocating rationality to people who want to be engineers, or is he just crowing about how much better engineers are than those stupid people in other fields who think they're just as smart?
  • Might be a nitpick, but speaking at all in terms of what one "believes in" rather than what's true is a bad habit.
  • It puts too much emphasis on conclusions rather than epistemology.
  • It sounds like "Believe what those cool people in lab coats say, not those freaks in robes", or "Believe things that sound scientific and modern, not things that sounds weird and fantastical".
  • It connotes that disbelieving in black magic is proof of a superior mind, rather than largely a fact about what culture one grew up in.
  • One should believe things that can't be verified by experiment.
Comment author: RobertLumley 03 October 2011 07:06:25PM 1 point [-]

Interesting, thanks. And good points. Someone had already PMed me their reason for downvoting though (not mentioned in your list), but didn't want to influence future votes.

Comment author: Document 03 October 2011 07:08:40PM 0 points [-]

I may have edited while you were reading; sorry if so.

Comment author: Document 03 October 2011 07:45:16PM *  0 points [-]

(I thought I got the phrase "cool people in lab coats" from a LW comment, but now it's joined the list of comments I can't find with Google.)