nshepperd comments on Not By Empathy Alone - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (108)
Not sure about this one, not least because I don't believe in deontology in the first place.
Is a moral judgement that is made for the sole reason of self-interest a moral judgement?
Presumably you don't need to empathize with yourself, since you already have direct access to your own feelings.
Actually a worthwhile point. Although empathy might make us care about victims in the first place, once that's established you just need to know that the action will result in victims to formulate a rule against it. This is because morality is about the victims, not about one's feelings about them.
Not terribly great examples, since I see no reason to care about most of these, but it is true that we're allowed to care about beautiful or interesting natural biomes for their own sake without "empathizing" with them, as we established in the previous "Not for the sake of X alone" discussions. (Although in most cases, destroying the place would have the effect of depriving possible future visitors of it, thereby creating victims.)