pedanterrific comments on On the Openness personality trait & 'rationality' - Less Wrong

42 Post author: gwern 14 October 2011 01:07AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (95)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: komponisto 14 October 2011 09:12:23AM 6 points [-]

The title had me captivated. However:

This post could use some more exposition in between the quotes. When "parasite load" was mentioned, my immediate assumption was that this was a metaphorical usage referring to "parasitic" ideas or memes, and was quite confused when I encountered a discussion of skin infections and whatnot, suggesting that somehow the literal sense of biological parasites was intended. This was confusing because I wasn't expecting any connection between psychological personality traits such as openness on the one hand and susceptibility to infectious disease on the other. Maybe such a connection is well-known in some circles, but I was totally unprepared for it and it came across to me as a bizarrely privileged hypothesis. Some more emphatic exposition, saying in effect "yes reader, I really do intend to relate the personality trait of openness to the medical phenomenon of infectious diseases" would have been helpful.

Comment author: pedanterrific 14 October 2011 02:28:09PM 2 points [-]

Um... were you, perhaps, reading out of order? Because "parasite load" is first mentioned in the between-quote exposition immediately after the block quote that is introduced and starts off with

On the potential biological negatives of novelty-seeking:

Each person's lymphocytes learn to fight off the particular varieties of parasites that are common within his own local group, ...

and includes the sentence

They should develop a more proactive "psychological immune system" to avoid getting their mouths, noses, genitals, or skin anywhere close to potential sources of infection.

which would be... interesting... if interpreted through the lens of parasitic memes.

Comment author: komponisto 14 October 2011 09:27:26PM 1 point [-]

Yes, I (first) thought that the purpose of that block quote was to introduce a metaphor.