Use your intuition!

I have. My gut didn't raise a red flag when I read AnnaSalamon's post, but it did when I read yours.

I am not sure what you are getting at.

I was giving a reason for my claim that there'd be someone on LW/in SI who'd be alienated by all but the blandest of strategies.

If she thinks that there are strategies that should be kept secrete for political reasons or whatever and admits it, that's bad from any possible viewpoint.

Maybe she thinks that and maybe she doesn't, but either way she didn't admit it. (At least not in the post I'm talking about. I haven't read AS's whole comment history.)