GabrielDuquette comments on A Rational Approach to Education - Less Wrong

-4 Post author: jrichardliston 16 November 2011 06:43PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (25)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: [deleted] 16 November 2011 08:53:17PM *  5 points [-]

John Taylor Gatto wrote extensively about this:

Comment author: endoself 16 November 2011 11:36:30PM 1 point [-]

I read the first article, and I have two questions.

First, what evidence is there that these people played an important role in the development of the school system. The article makes a good case if these were actually the influential people here, but it is clearly arguing for a specific conclusion, so I cannot trust it on this without further evidence. The implication that Carnegie was involved in this is particularly surprising, since his philanthropic creation of public libraries seems to pursue the opposite goal. Also, all the quotes were, as far as I recall from Americans. Do other countries have better public school systems, did they have their own evil plans, or did they copy blindly from the US?

Second, what is maintaining the current system? The people quoted mostly lived decades ago, but you seem to imply that inertia is not the only thing preventing reform.

Comment author: [deleted] 17 November 2011 12:20:31AM *  0 points [-]

I'm not implying anything. Your question made me think of Gatto, and I figured the signal-to-noise ratio in his writing would be worthwhile enough to recommend. I don't think I can respond to your questions until I've fully digested the book, but it's nowhere near the top of my reading list, so I don't anticipate that occurring soon.

Comment author: endoself 17 November 2011 01:07:16AM 1 point [-]

I'm not implying anything.

Sorry, I confused something Morendil wrote with you.

it's nowhere near the top of my reading list

Me too.