dlthomas comments on Several Topics that May or May Not deserve their own Post - Less Wrong

7 Post author: EphemeralNight 29 November 2011 01:59AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (69)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: dlthomas 29 November 2011 06:02:18PM 0 points [-]

For adults, though, I see "Why?" as the lazy question. It throws all the effort of actually formulating an answerable question on whoever tries to answer it.

I think this touches on something huge. Asking why, and seeking to answer it yourself, is not childish or annoying or looked down upon - it's science! Asking why, and expecting someone else to figure out the particular question and find an answer for you is absolutely childish. It may in fact be appropriate for a child, but it does hit a point where the work being demanded is far more than is appropriate to the interaction, and difficulty in dealing with this leads to frustration; it is not easy to explain to a child why asking "why?" and expecting the adult to provide a response in the context of a short interaction was reasonable the past 4 times and now is unreasonable.

Note that while I would say, "answer this for me" is generally childish, "come answer this with me" is more often not - I don't mean to exclude involvement by others. In all cases, though, it depends somewhat on circumstance.

Comment author: billswift 29 November 2011 08:07:56PM *  0 points [-]

Agreed that asking yourself why isn't childish, nor as in my earlier post is it "lazy" to ask it of yourself, but I don't think it is particularly useful either. "Why?" is too big a question to answer. You need to break it down into answerable bites, as science does as a practical matter in requiring testable hypotheses.

Comment author: dlthomas 30 November 2011 02:21:34AM 0 points [-]

Right. "Why?" is a starting point.