FeepingCreature comments on Urges vs. Goals: The analogy to anticipation and belief - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (71)
I so have to try this hack. No agency without urgency?
This fits in reasonably well with an anti-akrasia framework I've been thinking over: Rephrase goal X as "I honestly believe that I will achieve X", and then carry on thinking until you actually have a reasonably solid case for believing that. This particular trick translates to breaking down the statement into "I will force myself to develop an urge to do X. And once I have an urge to do X I will surely do X because I tend to follow my urges".
I think that those are sort of describing the same thing but at different levels of abstraction. Thinking in terms of evolutionary adaptations, our professed goals and actual behavior may differ for status/signaling reasons. But thinking about cognition we just come to the conclusion that we're not very agenty and aren't so bothered about the evolutionary reason why.
As a rationalist, you can frame that as "I prefer to reward future versions of me that have achieved this by having correctly predicted their behavior. "