JoshuaZ comments on Video Q&A with Singularity Institute Executive Director - Less Wrong

42 Post author: lukeprog 10 December 2011 11:27AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (122)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: JoshuaZ 12 December 2011 04:35:48AM 10 points [-]

For what it is worth, komponisto's basic point without the egotism is essentially correct. The dropping of the definite article sounds incredibly awkward and does signal either a scam or general incompetence. I don't understand what they are thinking. The self-congratulatory puffery that is the second half of the comment doesn't reduce the validity of the central point.

Comment author: komponisto 12 December 2011 08:44:58AM *  6 points [-]

The self-congratulatory puffery that is the second half of the comment doesn't reduce the validity of the central point.

Said "puffery" has now been removed. My own mental context for those remarks was evidently quite different from that in which they were seen by others. (Though no one actually complained until gwern, quite a while after the comment was posted.)

Comment author: wedrifid 12 December 2011 05:29:06PM *  8 points [-]

Said "puffery" has now been removed. My own mental context for those remarks was evidently quite different from that in which they were seen by others. (Though no one actually complained until gwern, quite a while after the comment was posted.)

It is amazing how much difference one antagonistic reader can make to how a statement is interpreted by others. Apart from the priming it makes you a legitimate target.

Comment author: komponisto 12 December 2011 09:18:01PM 7 points [-]

It is amazing how much difference one antagonistic reader can make to how a statement is interpreted by others. Apart from the priming it makes you a legitimate target.

Quite so. This "bandwagon" behavior is disturbing, and has the unfortunate consequence of incentivizing one to reply to hostile comments immediately (instead of taking time to reflect), to fend off the otherwise inevitable karma onslaught.

Comment author: gwern 12 December 2011 06:00:43PM 1 point [-]

Yes, I found Asch's Conformity Experiment pretty amazing too.