orthonormal comments on How can people be actually converted? - Less Wrong

5 Post author: yttrium 05 February 2012 10:13PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (94)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: [deleted] 06 February 2012 05:31:50PM 2 points [-]

Same thing at the academically best divinity schools in the US; they turn out a lot of non-theists, a fact that shocked me

Do you think this is intentional to find only the most devout preachers?

Comment author: orthonormal 06 February 2012 05:58:06PM 12 points [-]

Unlikely; I think it's more a case of lost purposes.

One notable case is that of the Jesuit order, which from its inception had the most extensive scriptural/theological/philosophical training (seven years before ordination) of any order. In previous centuries, this reliably produced extremely devoted and intelligent priests, who racked up massive numbers of conversions as missionaries.

However, as the field of scriptural studies changed in the 19th and 20th centuries, the Jesuits incorporated new historical-critical material which contradicted some of the traditional claims of the Old Testament. (It's to their credit that they did this, even if their reasoning was that knowing the exaggerations of the Old Testament surely wouldn't undermine the core of the faith.)

But as this process continued, eventually the Jesuits transformed into one of the most liberal of the Catholic orders. The original policy came at a time when the most educated people knew of little to contradict the Church, but the world changed.