Bill_McGrath comments on Art vs. science - Less Wrong

5 Post author: PhilGoetz 01 March 2012 11:09PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (15)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: Bill_McGrath 02 March 2012 07:00:56PM *  2 points [-]

My training in music composition focuses quite a bit on Famous Dead People; but using examples from their music. It's a case of "This is how Bach/Beethoven/Brahms/Schoenberg did this, it proved effective, you can possibly learn from it." We're not expected to write in pastiche styles however, rather to approach more fundamental issues of writing music with methods that have been shown to work.

I can't really see any other way TO approach it; the reason that Bach's strong basslines work is rooted in how humans perceive sound. The easiest way to pass this on is to provide examples.

EDIT: That said, I'd be interested in reading that Hindemith book. (Hilariously, in light of the current discussion, it's because he's a composer I'm interested in - a Famous Dead Person.) My supervisor wrote a paper on Hindemith's approach to teaching counterpoint, but I didn't realize he had textbooks.