amcknight comments on A taxonomy of Oracle AIs - Less Wrong

13 Post author: lukeprog 08 March 2012 11:14PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (51)

You are viewing a single comment's thread.

Comment author: amcknight 27 April 2012 12:20:15AM 0 points [-]

Very powerful Predictors are unsafe in a rather surprising way: when given sufficient data about the real world, they exhibit goal-seeking behavior, i.e. they calculate a distribution over future data in a way that brings about certain real-world states.

This isn't necessarily the case. What the loopiness of predictors shows is that a simple predictor is incomplete. How correct a prediction is depends on the prediction that is made (i.e. is loopy), so you need another criterion in order to actually program the predictor to resolve this case. One way to do this is by programming it to "select" predictions based on some sort of accuracy metric, but this is only one way. There may be other safer ways that make the predictor less agenty, such as answering "LOOPY" when its would-be predictions vary too much depending on which answer it could give.