Multiheaded comments on Examine your assumptions - Less Wrong

32 Post author: Douglas_Reay 30 March 2012 11:28AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (13)

You are viewing a single comment's thread.

Comment author: Multiheaded 30 March 2012 01:29:06PM 6 points [-]

It is a useful fable, but in the context presented it seemed unlikely, given the attitudes of Bomber Harris.

Hmm? Please elaborate.

Comment author: Randaly 30 March 2012 09:02:53PM *  11 points [-]

Harris was notoriously at accepting advice/criticism that contradicted his prior beliefs; many other times he was contradicted (eg on the utility of area bombing, on specific targets, on the use of his bombers by Coastal Command, etc) he reacted poorly- ignoring reports, stonewalling the other services or his superiors, and generally refusing to change Bomber Command policies. This would be doubly true in this case because Blackett worked for the Admiralty, and was disagreeing with a previous Bomber Command study. It's trebly true because he and Blackett had clashed repeatedly during the war- Blackett (and Henry Tizard) had (correctly) argued that Bomber Command's policy of area bombing was extremely ineffective, and some of its resources should be shifted to the other services, which Harris strongly disagreed with.

Comment author: Random832 12 April 2012 08:03:15PM 0 points [-]

The story doesn't actually say "and they put armor where Blackett suggested and everyone lived happily ever after", though.